The Ethical Debate Around Shearling: Is it Cruel?

Pologeorgis Furs

Posted on August 16 2023

The Ethical Debate Around Shearling: Is it Cruel?

Shearling could be considered a controversial material in the fashion industry, with concerns raised about its ethical implications. In this article, we will delve into the world of shearling, exploring what it is, how it is produced, and the associated animal welfare concerns. 

We will also discuss alternatives to shearling and the role consumers play in shaping the industry. Lastly, we will look into the future of shearling, examining potential technological innovations and changes in legislation. But first things first, what is shearling? 

What is Shearling?

Shearling is a type of sheepskin hide that has been processed in a specific way to preserve both the wool and the leather and it is commonly used to make jackets, coats, boots, and other winter accessories. 

The wool side of shearling is plush and soft, while the leather or suede side is smooth and supple. This combination of textures adds depth and visual interest to shearling garments, making them not only functional but also aesthetically pleasing. But how is this material produced? 

The 5 Steps to Producing Shearling

The production process for shearling involves several steps. 

  1. The sheep are raised for their wool and are typically shorn in the spring to harvest their wool. 
  2. After shearing, the sheepskins are carefully cleaned, treated, and preserved, ensuring that it retains longevity. 
  3. Skilled craftsmen then comb the wool side of the shearling to remove any tangles or impurities, resulting in a smooth and lustrous texture.
  4. After that, the wool undergoes a tanning process, which involves treating the sheepskin with natural or synthetic substances to enhance their durability. 
  5. Once the tanning process is complete, the shearling is inspected, ensuring that each piece is meticulously crafted. 

Understanding the production of shearling allows us to appreciate its value and make informed choices when it comes to ethical considerations. So let’s take a closer look at the debate surrounding this material. 

The Ethical Debate Around Shearling

Shearling is prized for its warmth and luxurious feel, but it is not without controversy. So let’s take a closer look at the ethical debate surrounding shearling and the production of this material. 

  1. Animal rights organizations argue that the conditions in which sheep are raised and sheared may subject them to unnecessary stress and potential harm as they are handled roughly and mistreated.
  2. In some industrialized shearing operations, sheep may be confined to small spaces, limiting their ability to engage in natural behaviors, which can lead to discomfort.
  3. Sheep may experience pain or discomfort if the shearing is rushed or if the shearers are not adequately trained. 
  4. In large-scale shearing operations, sheep may be treated as commodities rather than living beings and are packed into very tight spaces, which can increase the risk of disease transmission and stress-related behaviors. 
  5. The use of hormones and antibiotics to promote faster growth and prevent diseases may also raise concerns about the long-term health effects on sheep and potential impacts on human health.

This has led to more responsible practices that can mitigate potential ethical concerns, which includes transparent supply chains and certifications that guarantee a higher level of animal welfare standards. By supporting local shearling producers who prioritize ethical practices and adhere to strict guidelines, such as providing space for the sheep to graze, and regular veterinary care, consumers can contribute to the sustainability of the industry and the well-being of the sheep. Pologeorgis is one of the leading fur manufacturers that focuses on sustainable and ethical fur manufacturing.

The Consumer's Role in the Shearling Industry

In recent years, consumers have become more conscious of the ethical implications of their purchasing choices and have the power to shape the shearling industry by making informed purchasing decisions and supporting brands that prioritize animal welfare. So let’s take a look at a few tips to consider before purchasing your shearling. 

How to Make an Informed Decision on Shearling

When considering purchasing shearling products, there are a few things you can do as a consumer to ethically source your shearling. So let’s look at a few tips: 

  1. Research and choose brands that hold themselves to high ethical standards. 
  2. Look for certifications such as the Responsible Wool Standard (RWS) or the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) that ensure the materials meet certain animal welfare criteria.
  3. Consider supporting brands that have transparent supply chains and prioritize sustainable practices. 

When consumers actively choose brands that prioritize animal welfare, they send a clear message to the industry that unethical practices will not be tolerated. This can lead to a shift in the market, with brands being incentivized to improve their practices or risk losing customers to more ethical competitors.

By making informed purchasing decisions and supporting brands that prioritize animal welfare, you can contribute to a shift towards a more responsible and sustainable shearling industry. Now let’s take a look at what the future holds in store for the shearling industry. 

The Future of Shearling

The future of shearling is likely to be influenced by technological innovations, changes in legislation, evolving consumer preferences, and a growing awareness of ethical concerns surrounding animal welfare. Let’s take a look at a few examples: 

  1. Researchers are exploring innovative ways to create shearling-like materials using plant-based fibers or lab-grown wool, which are cruelty-free alternatives.
  2. Governments and organizations are recognizing the need for stricter regulations to ensure the humane treatment of sheep in shearling production.
  3. Consumer preferences are driving brands to explore innovative materials and production methods that minimize harm to animals and the environment.

With advancements in technology and shifts in industry standards, it is becoming increasingly feasible to produce shearling in a way that prioritizes animal welfare. By supporting brands committed to ethical practices, consumers can play a significant role in shaping the future. 

Last Thoughts on The Ethical Debate Around Shearling

The future of shearling is not only about warmth and luxury but also about addressing the ethical concerns associated with animal welfare. Technological innovations, changes in legislation, and evolving consumer preferences are all contributing to a more sustainable and compassionate future for shearling. 

As the industry continues to evolve, it is crucial for stakeholders to remain informed and actively participate in discussions surrounding animal welfare standards. By working together, we can create a future where fashion and compassion go hand in hand.

More Posts